Ecoknowledge

Ecoknowledge

Some thoughts on ecology, evolution and economics

On sexual selection

The peacock’s tail presented a problem for Charles Darwin.  It clearly could not have arisen by natural selection. Its beauty, extravagance, and most of all, its impracticality seemed to argue against the gradual increase, generation after generation, of such a structure within a population.

Darwin introduced a separate process, sexual selection, to explain the origin of traits whose only apparent function is to influence the choice of mates.  This process, like natural selection, would produce more offspring with the trait in question but would do so without reference to adaptation to the surrounding environment.  In some cases, Darwin argued, sexual selection could act in opposition to natural selection to produce impractical results.  I question whether such a process is plausible or even necessary to explain exaggerated traits.

 

Honest advertising

There is one way in which mating displays can evolve through natural selection.  If they are providing reliable information about which mate is better adapted to the environment, then the displays will increase in the population through linkage to the adapted traits.  An example in birds is the correlation between bright plumage and healthy immune systems. Of course, it helps if the selecting gender – often the girls- notice the mating display and are discerning about who they mate with.  The mix of adaptive and mating traits are passed on after adjusting for the inconvenience and cost of the mating display.  That is, peacocks with really heavy or awkward tails get selected out, while those that balance the needs of feeding, predator avoidance and attracting mates pass on their genes.  If the mating display no longer indicates a quality mate – when the display is all style and no substance- natural selection will tend to reward less attractive individuals who nonetheless yield a lot of offspring.

Sexy sons

There is an idea that sexual selection occurs when females mate with attractive males for the prospect of having attractive (and potentially reproductively successful) sons.  This is called the sexy son hypothesis. This amounts to the continuation of a fad over many generations.  Given the fact that human fashions and fads last a small fraction of a generation, it seems unlikely that such a process could be  important in evolution.  Ronald Fisher, a brilliant statistician and evolutionary biologist, came up with a possible explanation of what he called “runaway selection”.  The mating display is linked, not with a useful trait for survival as in the example above, but to a genetic preference for the display when choosing a mate.  This could happen if 1) the genes for the mating display and the genes that influence the choice of that display occur close together on the same chromosome and tend to get inherited together and 2) the mating display doesn’t pose a disadvantage that natural selection would weed out.  The offspring of a male with an exaggerated display(e.g. larger antlers,  longer nose or  brighter tail) and a female with a genetic disposition to choose  that display will reinforce the frequency of the trait and its selection in the next generation.  These two traits have to arise spontaneously at about the same time or else the process will not work.  It is possible to have a display chosen without any genetic preference for  a few generations simply on the basis of choosing familiar looking males.  However, novelty and other survival characteristics will soon crowd out such a meaningless display unless the gene for choosing such a mate also appears in the population.  To me, it is implausible that two genes will   appear close together on a chromosome at about the same time having to do with the same structure.  If such a thing does occur it must be very rare.

Signal amplification

There is a simpler way that mating displays can arise.  If a small population is reproductively isolated (see Limits of natural selection ) then there is potential for new mating displays to arise by genetic drift alone.  Still, it seems odd that genetic drift (literally, random change in the frequency of traits)  would yield such extreme structures.  If a small group of males are competing to attract mates it makes sense that the ones with the most extravagant display will have the biggest impact on the females, regardless of what their genetic preferences are.  In communication, a clear, strong signal is needed to stand out from a background of competing signals.   In this way, genetic drift can be drawn towards extreme (large, colorful or elaborate) mating structures in small populations without adding any assumptions of linked genes or hidden function.

In the end, it is possible that neither natural or sexual selection is involved in the origin of the peacock’s tail.   In fact, if Darwin had seen the potential for reproductive isolation to establish new species, the issue may never have come up.

 

20 Responses to On sexual selection

  1. Стильные советы по созданию отличных образов на каждый день.
    Обзоры профессионалов, события, все дропы и мероприятия.
    https://moismi.ru/info/2024-09-15-istoriya-brenda-baldinini-ot-remeslennogo-proizvodstva-do-mezhdunarodnogo-uspeha/

    Permalink
  2. The OTU domain is also found in related nairoviruses Dugbe virus DUGV and Nairobi sheep disease virus how to buy priligy im 16 years old

    Permalink
  3. Exercise pants with pouches are exceptionally convenient and practical. These trousers exist with built-in pouches that exist as great for storing your basics such as your mobile keychains or money holder. The compartments are tactically located to guarantee that your belongings persist safe while you move. Fitness leggings with pockets are great for any activity from exercising to running chores. The stretchy cloth permits for a complete scope of movement delivering relaxation and support. Match them with a camisole or athletic bra for a complete exercise ensemble. With different styles and colors presented you can locate the perfect set to match your requirements. Keep systematic and trendy with exercise pants with compartments. Their practicality and utility render them a must-have in any closet. High Elasticity Breeches Remain Stylish with Plain Single Color Capris 2c82bbc

    Permalink
  4. Стильные советы по созданию модных образов на каждый день.
    Статьи профессионалов, новости, все коллекции и мероприятия.
    https://omskdaily.ru/novosti/2024-09-20-7-interesnyh-faktov-o-vetements-ot-antiglamura-do-modnogo-fenomena/

    Permalink
  5. Marketing your home for funds and flipping real estate for income can be an excellent method to create income in the housing industry but it demands comprehensive planning and readiness. Start by precisely assessing your propertys marketplace price which you can attain through professional appraisals evaluations with comparable residences or online valuation resources. Proper valuing is essential to prevent economic shortfalls or prolonged selling periods. Seeking a housing agent can provide valuable advice to assist you establish a reasonable and accurate cost based on current sector conditions. Before offering your house for cash emphasize on performing essential improvements and upgrades notably in critical spaces like the cooking area and bathrooms which can greatly boost your homes worth and attractiveness. Verifying that your estate is clean and clean is essential to luring prospective purchasers quickly. Additionally preparing your house by organizing organizing furnishings carefully and introducing elegant decor can create an inviting environment that enhances buyer attraction. Hiring a certified home arranger can additionally improve your house’s appearance. For those looking to revolve houses for profit securing the appropriate funding is vital. Alternatives such as traditional financial institution funds private loans and personal loans are accessible and its necessary to choose one that fits with your monetary condition and undertaking needs. Ensure you have a robust repayment approach in place. Working with the proper experts such as property agents renovators assessors and law experts is essential for a effective house renovating project. These specialists can help in discovering the best estate handling fixes evaluating property status and overseeing law-related issues ensuring a smooth and lucrative flipping procedure. For additional information and resources on this topic kindly check my top site. Should you want see more about this one topic have a look at my web-site: fast buy home for money by atlanta GA and South Fulton Union City GA 30291 Grasping the Repair Process in House Flipping 0be5670

    Permalink
  6. Стильные заметки по созданию стильных видов на каждый день.
    Мнения стилистов, события, все коллекции и шоу.
    https://omskdaily.ru/news/2024-09-20-10-samyh-vliyatelnyh-dizaynerov-2024-goda-trendsettery-kotorye-izmenyayut-modu/

    Permalink
  7. Профессиональный сервисный центр по ремонту бытовой техники с выездом на дом. Мы предлагаем: ремонт бытовой техники в краснодаре Наши мастера оперативно устранят неисправности вашего устройства в сервисе или с выездом на дом

    Permalink
  8. Matt Michael DAgati is the proprietor of RW a Solar Firm in Massachusetts. A few years of time ago taking an adventurous journey Matt DAgati stepped into the realm of alternative energy plus in a short moments commenced efficiently promoting significant amounts of power predominately over the business industry collaborating with developers of solar farms and local businesses in the planning of a campaigns. Consistent networks after only the sector led Matthew to unite a inter city startup 2 period of time prior and within a brief period he became their Chief Strategy Officer responsible for all calculations and commercial development along with being sold community possession. From specific jvs and shear move ethic Matthew DAgati boosted that team from an initial 1st-year pay to over a 150 maximize in porcine revenues by same year two. Building on that basis Renewables Worldwide’s RW an veteran-possessed company was designed with the quest of supplying alternative vigor treatments for an intelligent and more renewable future. Greater really understanding there is a niche in the advertise and an improved approach to maintain outcome RW is one of the few manufactures in the U . S . to notice on guest learning concentrating in both business and residence sunlight work off-take. Their eyesight is to formulate a marketing substructure on a community-based statewide national level offering a multitude of replenishable focus features through the of RW. This passion in that the alternative industry proceeds to stimulate and inspire Matt in proceeding his journey to work with associations that reveal the even of supplying natural electricity choices for a considerably renewable future. Matthew presents each in firm from Hesser College. The ways NH solar power is changing the energy landscape guided through the expertise of Matthew dagati. Switching to Carbon-neutral Methods: Obstacles and Prospects from matt dagatiMatt DAgati be5670_

    Permalink
  9. Модные советы по подбору крутых луков на любой день.
    Обзоры профессионалов, новости, все коллекции и шоу.
    https://superlooks.ru/look/1165-vybiraem-originalnye-krossovki-balenciaga/

    Permalink
  10. What Recruiting An Public Assistance Inability Attorney Is Necessary. Recruiting The SSA Incapacity Attorney Is Critical. The Social Services Allocation Supervises several efforts from job-loss protection to social aid and also takes care of incapacity remuneration for individuals not able to carry out tasks due to ongoing medical conditions or wound. As with any sophisticated body there are guidelines and rules which must be followed by the aforementioned agency in order to obtain advantages. In need of the Knowledgeable attorney for SSA Can be essential. Bringing on the seasoned SSD law practitioner could assist you manage the complications of SSA SSI raising your possibility of endorsement for advantages. They might confirm that your application is submitted accurately and includes supporting medical evidence; besides they understand how to accumulate this evidence speedily so it is not presented late; also they could prevent giving irrelevant data that will result in holdups and denials by the Secure Social Allocation. Your specialized professional in disabilities will also prime you for a hearing with SSA if your claim is rejected by detailing what to expect at it and answering any of your inquiries about what happens there. They could support with offering additional evidence and asking the magistrate who heard your lawsuit to assess their decision and interrogate witnesses or career professionals called by Social Security to testify on your behalf which could increase the probability that an primary appeal for disability wins if originally denied. Legal professionals in social security disability may recover any past due perks thanks to changes in the starting date which indicates when your ailment began. Effective disability supporters will assist with regaining any past due perks that may have been lost attributable to changes in the starting date or when your situation began. Meeting the criteria for Social Security Disability necessitates a thorough assessment of the severity of your conditions The Critical Services Provided by an Counsel Experienced in Disability Law 7f1541b

    Permalink
  11. Clean exteriors play a vital role in increasing patron engagement for dining establishments and bistros. High-pressure washing will substantially boost the look of dining establishments by eliminating dust blemishes and graffiti. A clean and in good condition exterior creates a positive first impression attracting potential customers to stop by. Furthermore power washing patios and paths guarantees a enjoyable eating experience rid of debris. This can lead to higher customer visits favorable feedback and word-of-mouth referrals eventually increasing sales. Investing in regular power washing aids dining establishments ensure a hospitable and sanitary appearance important for bringing in and keeping customers. If youre keen feel free to check out my domestic and corporate pressure cleaning services website to discover more. Warehouse/Commercial building Steam wash around San Francisco County as well as Walnut Creek CA for Truck and trailers dealerships Preparing Business Premises for Painting 52c82bb

    Permalink
  12. Patek Philippe is a prestigious Swiss watchmaker known for its luxury timepieces. Founded in 1839, the brand continues to uphold its heritage of superior craftsmanship. Luxury watch fans seek out Patek Philippe due to its engineering feats and unique models.
    https://patek.superpodium.com

    Permalink
  13. На данной платформе вы можете приобрести изделия бренда знаменитого бренда Loro Piana. Каталог товаров включает эксклюзивные продукцию, изготовленные с использованием высококачественных материалов и передовых технологий. Оцените мир настоящей роскоши, который предлагает Loro Piana.
    https://loropiana.whitezorro.ru

    Permalink
  14. Вещи бренда Balmain доступны для покупки в нашем магазине. Откройте для себя коллекцию эксклюзивных моделей от знаменитого французского бренда
    Купить Balmain

    Permalink
  15. Профессиональный сервисный центр по ремонту Apple iPhone в Москве. Мы предлагаем: ремонт айфонов на дому в москве Наши мастера оперативно устранят неисправности вашего устройства в сервисе или с выездом на дом

    Permalink
  16. Профессиональный сервисный центр по ремонту Apple iPhone в Москве. Мы предлагаем: мастер ремонта apple Наши мастера оперативно устранят неисправности вашего устройства в сервисе или с выездом на дом

    Permalink
  17. Профессиональный сервисный центр по ремонту Apple iPhone в Москве. Мы предлагаем: ремонт iphone в москве Наши мастера оперативно устранят неисправности вашего устройства в сервисе или с выездом на дом

    Permalink
  18. Бренд Tissot — известный Швейцарский производитель наручных устройств, что славится своим первоклассным качеством и элегантным дизайном. Уже более столетия с половиной компания производит современные хронометры, что пользуются уважение по всему миру.
    https://tissot.icefashion.ru

    Permalink
  19. Премиальный интернет-магазин Боттега Венета предлагает полный каталог эксклюзивных товаров от легендарного бренда. На сайте вы сможете выбрать и приобрести изделия последних поступлений с доставкой по Москве и России.
    https://bottega-official.ru

    Permalink
  20. Snasdxxxax.Snasdxxxax

    Permalink

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes:
<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>